GTA 6 Hey Arnold!: should you kill or spare Arnold? Every outcome (and the $10,000 text)
Kill or spare Arnold is the first big choice of GTA 6 and everyone is searching for it today. Here is what each option changes, the hidden third option, and why sparing him pays off much later.
Spoiler warning: Chapter 1 mission Hey Arnold!, with a hint about a later chapter.
In Hey Arnold!, a Chapter 1 story mission given by Brian (listed as mission 8 by several walkthrough videos), Jason chases Arnold on foot and corners him at the end of a jetty, on the dock near Jason's house (Game8). The game then asks you to kill him or spare him. Radio Times, Game Rant, Game8, Eurogamer and Mashable all published guides on Thursday: here is the consensus.
Kill or spare: what each choice does
| Choice | Immediate result |
|---|---|
| Kill Arnold | Hardened criminal profile points. No further interactions with Arnold (Game8). |
| Spare Arnold | Restrained criminal profile points. Arnold jumps into the sea and swims away. |
| Do nothing | After a while Arnold says he will just swim away: same result as sparing him, Restrained (Game Rant, Game8). |
Game Rant adds that you cannot shoot him once he is swimming, and that if you wait too long the game decides for you. Either way, the next scene is identical: Jason tells Brian that Arnold will keep his mouth shut, and Brian introduces him to the treasure hunter Kenton, which unlocks the mission Island Dreams (Game Rant, Radio Times). Game Rant warns that Island Dreams hides a less obvious, and much more gruesome, choice of its own.
The long-term payoff: $10,000
This is why the choice is trending. According to Radio Times, if you spare Arnold, much later in the story Brian texts you to say he ended up forgiving him, and you receive $10,000 as a thank-you (Radio Times says the money comes from Arnold). Gamers Heroes, quoted by Hindustan Times, places that message in Chapter IV. Kill him and nothing bad happens, but you will never get that money.

Official Rockstar screenshot of Brian Heder, who gives Jason the Hey Arnold! mission. Source: rockstargames.com/VI.
Our advice
Spare him. It costs you nothing in the short term, you keep the possibility of meeting Arnold again (Game8) and you collect $10,000 later. The criminal profile impact is small: Radio Times points out that you will make hundreds of other decisions before the end. Game8 notes that your profile influences how you raise Focus; see our wanted level and criminal profile guide for how the system works, and our list of missables and points of no return for the other choices to think about. Does Arnold affect the Jason and Lucia endings? No source has shown any link so far.
Video (full mission, spoilers)
Video: GTA 6 Mission #8 - Hey Arnold! (Chapter 1) [Full Walkthrough – PS5 4K] on YouTube, GTA Series Videos.
Another Chapter 1 character everyone is talking about: is Mandy a serial killer?
Sources
Written on 19 November 2026 at 14:30, Paris time (Europe/Paris). We will update this page as new finds are confirmed.
- Radio Times: Should you kill Arnold or spare him in GTA 6? (19 Nov 2026)
- Game Rant: Should You Shoot or Spare Arnold in GTA 6? (Hey Arnold!)
- Game8: Should You Kill or Spare Arnold?
- Hindustan Times (citing Gamers Heroes and Game8): Not killing Arnold in GTA VI could help Jason and Lucia get $10,000 later
- Also covered by Eurogamer, Mashable and Clarín on 19 Nov 2026
- YouTube: GTA Series Videos